Book Review Archives

The Meaning of Human Existence

The Meaning of Human Existence

By Edward O. Wilson
Liveright Publishing Company, a division of W. W. Norton & Co., 2014
$23.95, Hardcover


Reviewed by Don Noble

What writer/thinker would have the expertise, the wisdom, the confidence, and the courage to write a book titled The Meaning of Human Existence? The subject is infinite and eternal, not to mention wildly controversial. Luckily, there is such a person: E. O. Wilson, Harvard Professor of Biology Emeritus, two-time winner of the Pulitzer Prize, author of over twenty books, inventor, one might say, of sociobiology, expert on ants and superorganisms of all kinds, premier ecologist, and, one could argue, the Francis Bacon, the Charles Darwin, of our time.

At eighty-five years of age, Wilson is done holding back. In this powerful, slim volume he addresses the Big Questions and many readers will not be happy with his answers.

Among those unhappy will be the deniers of evolution, some 46% of Americans, and a “comparable fraction of Muslims worldwide” whose “minds are closed to the overwhelming mass of factual demonstrations … [and who] ignore, or more precisely … call it virtue to remain ignorant of ongoing evolution observed in the field …. [and even] new species created in the laboratory.”

Humans were not created, he insists, by God “in one to several magical mega-strokes.”

Rather, “our planet was born about 4.54 billion years ago,” the Milky Way galaxy is nearly 14 billion years old, and evolution has been under way for six hundred million years, not via “advance design, but instead [through] overlapping networks of physical cause and effect.” Nevertheless, Wilson believes, humans are not the servants of instinct or environment.

Wilson says that, paradoxically, “Human existence may be simpler than we thought. There is no predestination, no unfathomed mystery of life. Demons and gods do not vie for our allegiance. Instead we are self-made, independent, alone and fragile….”

Wilson acknowledges an innate spirituality in humans: all societies have religions, which offer “enormous psychological benefits to the believers.” Religious faith “gives them an explanation for their existence. It makes them feel loved and protected above members of every other tribal group.”

Further, he says, “It binds groups more strongly, and provides comfort to their members. It promotes charity and law-abiding behavior.”

Unfortunately, he argues, blind religious faith, especially tied to a strong creation story, leads to tribalism. God favors us, believers think, above all others. This “leads with frightening ease to racism and religious bigotry.” Members of other religions “worship the wrong gods, use wrong rituals, follow false prophets, and believe fantastic creation stories.” The great religions are, he asserts, “tragically, sources of ceaseless and unnecessary suffering.”

“Faith is the one thing,” Wilson says, “that makes otherwise good people do bad things.”

There are lighter chapters as well.

Given the size of the universe, one hundred billion or more galaxies, with our Milky Way containing a hundred billion star systems, there is probably life somewhere else. Wilson even speculates what ET’s might look like: like ET!— a largish land animal with a big head to contain a large brain, long flexible fingers to build the spaceship in the first place, with an audiovisual sensory system. If aliens study our planet, Wilson reminds us, they will learn nothing from our science or technology—after all, they knew how to get here—but they will be astounded by our humanistic/artistic achievements. They will be in awe of Shakespeare and Beethoven, not wearable computers which read out our heart rate.

But ET shouldn’t land here. Since ET evolved differently, our microbes would kill him. And because of the hundreds of light years distance, we aren’t colonizing “there” anytime soon.

No, this is our planet, forever, and he once again warns us not to poison the air and the water and to love one another and the other species, not exterminate them. There is much cause for hope; we will soon be able to eliminate many diseases through genetic engineering and, “in time, likely no more than several decades, we will be able to explain the dark matter of the Universe, the origin of life on Earth, and the physical basis of human consciousness during changes of mood and thought.” But he advises strongly against genetic engineering which would change human nature itself.

We should choose to remain “uniquely messy, self-contradictory, internally conflicted, endlessly creative.” In this he insists we should be “existential conservatives.”

In an era when the arts and humanities seem to be receding in favor of an emphasis on STEM—science, technology, engineering, and mathematics—Wilson the scientist stresses vociferously the role of the humanities in making us human. We are a story-telling, story-loving species.

We learn via stories, remember via stories. We love gossip, the minutiae of other people’s lives.

Although he calls humans “an innately dysfunctional species” and says that “we chatter constantly about destroying [our world] –by nuclear war, climate change, an apocalyptic Second Coming foretold by Holy Scripture,” Wilson believes that “human beings are not wicked by nature.” Rather, “we have enough intelligence, goodwill, generosity, and enterprise to turn Earth into a paradise both for ourselves and for the biosphere that gave us birth.”

Don Noble is host of the Alabama Public Television literary interview show Bookmark and the editor of A State of Laughter: Comic Fiction from Alabama. This review was originally broadcast on Alabama Public Radio.